1776 the Musical

1776 the Musical: May 7 – 17, 2026

Directed by Will Knappen

Photo of the cast from 1776
The cast of 1776

Abrams Spotlight Productions is celebrating the 250th birthday of our nation with 1776 the Musical, a bold, witty, and powerful musical that brings the signing of the Declaration of Independence to life. With sharp dialogue, rousing music, and moments of humor and heart, 1776 follows the debates, compromises, and larger-than-life personalities of America’s founding fathers as they struggle to unite thirteen colonies into one nation.


Synopsis

It is a long hot summer in Philadelphia, and the Continental Congress is an exhausted, annoyed, quarrelsome collection of men, at each other’s throats over the burning question of independence from Great Britain. John Adams, the passionate crusader for rebellion, races against time: if the congress does not agree to throw off the yoke of tyranny, General Washington’s painfully outnumbered army will have no ideal for which to fight. But Adams is obnoxious and disliked — no one will listen to his arguments. They might have a chance if Thomas Jefferson, that silver wordsmith, would write a Declaration — but Jefferson, frustrated by his long absence from lovely wife Martha, is in no mood to be creative. And when it comes down to a final decision, the course of history hangs on whether sycophantic Judge James Wilson can remain as anonymous as possible with his vote….. Under these conditions, how will America ever achieve Independence? Peter Stone and Sherman Edwards’ 1776 is a brilliant imagining of American history, a grand tale which manages to feel both intimate and epic at once, bringing humor and humanity to the account of twenty men, three months, and one incredible argument, in which the fate of nations is decided. The score features such famous tunes as the romantic “He Plays the Violin,” the comedic “The Lees of Old Virginia,” and that plaintive memorial to young patriots, “Momma, Look Sharp.”


Who’s Who? The Cast of 1776

  • John Hancock: (Mike Eserkaln)
    • President of the 1776 Continental Congress, John Hancock, put the first and largest signature on the Declaration of Independence. 
  • Dr. Josiah Bartlett: (Brian Kohls)
    • A New Hampshire delegate.  Dr. Josiah Bartlett sides in favor of independence. 
  • John Adams: (Matt Worzala)
    • A Massachusetts delegate, John Adams is the leading voice for separation from England and the Declaration of Independence. Unfortunately his tendency toward fiery rhetoric makes him generally disliked by other Congress members.
  • Stephen Hopkins: (David Jolly) 
    • A Rhode Island delegate, Stephen Hopkins is given to indulgence in alcoholic beverages. 
  • Roger Sherman: (Mary Spencer)
    • A Connecticut delegate, Roger Sherman sides in favor of independence and is on the committee to write the Declaration. 
  • Lewis Morris: (Julie Johannes-Frohliger)
    • A New York delegate, Lewis Morris abstains from the original vote. 
  • Robert Livingston: (Ryan Hibbard)
    • A New York delegate, Robert Livingston is a member of the committee assigned to write the Declaration. 
  • Reverend John Witherspoon: (Maggie Monte-Knaapen)
    • A New Jersey delegate, the Reverend John Witherspoon, argues for, and wins, the inclusion of the Supreme Being in the Declaration.
  • Benjamin Franklin: (Drew Pamperin)
    • A Pennsylvania delegate, Benjamin Franklin is urbane and coolheaded. His logic often prevails where the emotions of other fail. He and Adams lead the charge for independence. 
  • John Dickinson: (Ariana Gibeault)
    • A Pennsylvania delegate, John Dickinson leads a group of Congress members who favor petitioning King George III with their grievances rather than declaring independence from England.
  • James Wilson: (Julie Johannes-Frohliger)
    • A Pennsylvania delegate, James Wilson casts the final vote to approve the Declaration, not because of his own belief in the cause, but because he does not want to be remembered in history as “the man who prevented American independence.” 
  • Caesar Rodney: (David Retzlaff)
    • A Delaware delegate, Caesar Rodney works hard for independence, despite the fact that he is suffering from skin cancer. 
  • Colonel Thomas McKean: (Maggie Dernehl)
    • A Delaware delegate, Colonel Thomas McKean is Scottish and very vocal. 
  • George Read: (Rolean Wernicke)
    • A Delaware delegate, George Read is opposed to independence and sides with Dickinson. 
  • Samuel Chase: (Xander Birschbach)
    • A Maryland delegate, Samuel Chase always seems to be eating and is portly. He initially sides with Dickinson.
  • Richard Henry Lee: (Dan Potvin)
    • A Virginia delegate, Richard Henry Lee is selected to make the argument for independence to the Congress, as Adams is having little luck. 
  • Thomas Jefferson: (Bobby Buffington)
    • A Virginia delegate, Thomas Jefferson, in spite of his many protests, is selected to pen the Declaration of Independence. 
  • Joseph Hewes: (Mark Wernicke)
    • A North Carolina delegate, Joseph Hewes sides with Rutledge on the slavery issue, demanding the Declaration allow slavery. 
  • Edward Rutledge: (Will Knaapen)
    • A South Carolina delegate, Edward Rutledge is opposed to the Declaration of Independence because of his passionate opposition to the document’s call for an end to slavery. 
  • Dr. Lyman Hall: (Brian Prestley)
    • A Georgia delegate, Dr. Lyman Hall initially sides with Dickinson. 
  • Charles Thompson: (Allison Carter)
    • The secretary of the Congress. 
  • Andrew McNair: (Kelsey Steeno)
    • The custodian and bell-ringer  
  • Abigail Adams: (Maggie Monte-Knaapen)
    • Wife of John Adams, her communications with John tell some of the story of the Declaration and much of the story of her and John’s love and life. 
  • Martha Jefferson: (Julie Johannes-Frohliger)
    • The young and beautiful wife of Thomas Jefferson, Martha Jefferson is brought to Philadelphia to help dispel Jefferson’s writer’s block. 
  • Leather Apron: (Dan Potvin)
    • MacNair’s assistant
  • Painter: (Xander Birschbach)
  • Courier: (Ellie Finger)

Legally Blonde

Legally Blonde – The Musical (February 26 – March 8, 2026)

Program can be found here!

Directed by Preston Pelegrin

The cast of Legally Blonde, the Musical.
The cast of Legally Blonde, the Musical.

Meet the Cast of Legally Blonde!

Principal Roles

  • Elle – Maddie Budner
  • Emmett – Steven Blohowiak
  • Paulette – Elizabeth Jolly-Haslitt
  • Professor Callahan – Jerah Doxtator
  • Warner – Bobby Buffington
  • Vivienne Kensington – Carolyn Silverberg
  • Brooke Wyndham – Ali Carlson
  • Enid – Abby Frank
  • Margot – Julie Johannes-Frohliger
  • Serena – Hailey Marquardt
  • Pilar – Hayden Beekman
  • Gaelen – Erin Demro
  • Leilani – Sydney Surber
  • Chutney – Allison Carter
  • Dewey – Trent VandeWalle
  • Kyle – Joe Haslitt
  • Whitney – Ellie Finger

Delta Nu’s

  • Jennifer Hibbard
  • Amy Theuerkauf
  • Xandriana Rhode

Ensemble

  • Nick Blaser
  • McKenna Coffey
  • Avery Spratlin

Featuring:

  • Bruiser – Gizmo Reimer
  • Rufus – Bruce Pelegrin

Synopsis
Based on the novel and the hit-movie of the same name, Legally Blonde: the Musical chronicles the journey of the famously perky Elle Woods, a fashion-savvy, UCLA sorority girl who finds her life turned upside down when she is dumped by her boyfriend Warner. In an effort to prove to Warner that she is more than just some blonde sorority girl, she follows him to Harvard Law, where she struggles to fit in and do well. Ultimately, she defies expectations and manages to stay true to her delightfully pink personality.

Parental discretion advised. Some dialog and themes may not be appropriate for young children.


Any other questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us via email at theater.aspi@gmail.com or by calling the box office at 920-826-5852.


Magic Tree House

Magic Tree House Presents: A Ghost Tale for Mr. Dickens Jr!

December 4 – 14, 2025

Meet the Cast of Magic Tree House Presents: A Ghost Tale for Mr. Dickens Jr! ✨

We are so excited to announce the incredible young performers who will bring this magical holiday story to life. From Jack and Annie’s time-traveling adventure, to Charles Dickens, to the spirited ensemble—this cast is full of talent! 🎭

🌟 Featured Roles:

Morgan Le Fay – Nora Hatch

Merlin – Joey Martin

Jack – Trent VandeWalle

Annie – Claire Harkins

Dickens – Patrick O’Brien

Emma – Amelia Holtger

Olive – Elyse Finger

Mrs. Tibbs – Jillian Johnson

Collin – Hank Nicholson

Harry – Hannah Nicholson

Mrs. Pinch – Hailey Marquardt

Mr. Pinch – Nick Blaser

White Ghost – Lindsay Faris

Green Ghost – Jesslyn Beaumia

Black Ghost – Ruby Anderson

Caroler #1 – Elyse Finger

Caroler #2 – Lucille McDowell

Young Caroler – Amelia Holtger

Carriage Driver/Cabbie – Caitlin Harkins

Carriage Horses – Teagan Tessmer & Alaina McGrew

🎶 Ensemble:

Alaina McGrew, Amelia Martin, Anna Flory, Aubrey McGown, Audrina Larsen, Tristyn Larsen, Cassidy Mikol, Dorothy Masse, Elaina Finger, Ember Gossen, Evelyn Gossen, Emmerson Kuhn, Evette Campbell, Branny Jones, Fayda Jones, Kyla Karcz, Lilah Jones, Lily Woodke, Lillian McDowell, Michael McDowell, Clara Faris, Bree Hatch, Linden O’Brien, Emmett O’Brien

👏 Congratulations to the entire cast—we can’t wait to see you shine on stage this holiday season!

The Play That Goes Wrong

The Play That Goes Wrong

May 8, 9, 10, 11 and May 15, 16, 17, 18

Get your tickets now for a night of mishaps, mischief, and madcap mania! It’s the opening night of the Cornley Drama Society’s newest production, “The Murder at Haversham Manor,” and things have quickly gone from bad…to utterly disastrous. The troupe’s ambitious 1920s whodunit has everything you never want in a show: falling props, collapsing scenery, an unconscious leading lady, a corpse that can’t play dead, and actors who trip over everything…including their lines. How will this eager ensemble battle against all of the disastrous odds? Will they make it to the final curtain call?

An international hit that’s equal parts Monty Python and Sherlock Holmes – The Play That Goes Wrong is full of hilarious perfection.

Abrams Spotlight Productions is thrilled to introduce our cast of “The Play that Goes Wrong”. As the Director says “it’s gonna be a WILD show!”

Cast Name (Role)

  • Chris Mayse (Chris/Director)
  • Maddie Pamperin (Annie/Stage Manager)
  • Jerah Doxtator (Trevor/Lights and Sound Guy)
  • Maggie Monte-Knaapen (Sandra/Florence)
  • Bobby Buffington (Max/Cecil/Arthur the Gardener)
  • Eric Westphal (Perkins/Dennis)
  • Erick Gyrion (Thomas Colleymore/Robert Grove)
  • Matt Worzala (Jonathan/Charles Haversham)
  • Will Knaapen (Stage Crew)
  • Marly Thomson (Stage Crew)
  • Julie Johannas-Frohlinger (Stage Crew)
  • Mike Eserkaln (The Director, for real, he’s really the director of the show)
  • Maggie Dernehl (Assistant Director, the one helping Mike)

Tickets are on sale NOW!

The Play That Goes Wrong

GODSPELL

Godspell logo

Performed by Abrams Spotlight Productions in March 2025, Godspell is a musical in two acts with music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz and a book by John-Michael Tebelak. The show is structured as a series of parables, primarily based on the Gospel of Matthew, interspersed with music mostly set to lyrics from traditional hymns, with the passion of Christ appearing briefly near the end.

The cast of Godspell:

Jesus

Bobby Buffington

John the Baptist / Judas

Preston Pelegrin

Disciples of Jesus

Carolyn Silverberg

Hayden Beekman

Ali Carlson

Bill Sergott

Glenn Sellen

Teresa Aportela Sergott

Kari Moody

Jerah Doxtator

Maggie Sergott

Brynna Moody

Karen Olson

Hailey Marquardt

Jennifer Harkins

Debra Jolly

Elizabeth Jolly-Haslitt (Director)

Seussical the Musical presented by Abrams Theater December 5-15 2024

ASPI Brings Dr. Seuss Characters to Life in ‘Seussical’

The Cat in the Hat with Jojo

Abrams Spotlight Productions Inc. invites you into the world of Dr. Seuss to revisit beloved characters including The Cat in the Hat, Horton the Elephant, Gertrude McFuzz, Lazy Mayzie, and JoJo.

“Seussical the Musical,” directed by Debra Jolly, will be presented Dec. 5-8 and 12-15 at the Nancy Byng Community Theater, 5852 Maple St., Abrams. Anyone interested in helping behind the scenes can contact ASPI to volunteer.

“Seussical” weaves a story of friendship, loyalty, and love. The Cat in the Hat guides us into The Jungle of Nool where we see Horton, the kind-hearted elephant who discovers a speck of dust containing Whoville. He meets JoJo, a Who child sent to military school for thinking too many “thinks.”

“Seussical” is presented through special arrangement with Music Theatre International (MTI). All authorized performance materials are also supplied by MTI. Music by Stephen Flaherty, lyrics by Lynn Ahrens, and book by Lynn Ahrens and Stephen Flaherty. Based on the works of Dr. Seuss.

To order tickets, visit abramsspotlightproductions.com or call the box office, 920-826-5852.

Horton with the Sour Kangaroo

THANK YOU from the Boeing Boeing cast and crew!

Gallery of pictures from the Boeing Boeing cast and crew

Boeing Boeing has closed, and the flight has taken off. However, we are immensely grateful to the community for your support! We had amazing crowds for our summer comedy of the 2024 season.

In meeting and conversing with the patrons of the show, we had some inquiries that we wanted to address!

1) How can I get involved in an ASPI show? When is your next audition opportunity?

Seussical the Musical is our next production, opening in December. Auditions for Seussical are on August 27th or 28th at the theater. Visit our website to learn more about what to prepare! If you’d prefer to help behind the scenes instead of auditioning, we’d love to have you! We also have non-show-related volunteering opportunities available. For more information, please contact us at theater.aspi@gmail.com or call us at 920-826-5852!

2) How can I support ASPI financially?

ASPI is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization that depends on community support, both through volunteers and financial contributions. We have various funds available for donations, each offering Spotlight Sponsor benefits based on the level of donation. Some ongoing campaigns include our “Light the Way” Capital Campaign and the Hollie Surber Memorial Scholarship fund. To donate today or to learn more about our campaigns and Spotlight Sponsor membership benefits visit our website.

3) When do Seussical the Musical tickets go on sale?

Tickets for the general public will go on sale on October 5th. Prior to that, presale tickets will be available to our Spotlight Sponsors and Season Ticket holders starting on September 5th. If you’re interested in securing presale tickets, you can become a Spotlight Sponsor by clicking on the donation link below. This will be a popular show, so make sure to mark your calendars!

4) What is your 2025 season?

We are currently in the process of selecting our shows for the next season! The big reveal will happen in October, so please follow us on Facebook and Instagram to stay updated. Season tickets for 2025 will also be available for purchase in October. We are thrilled about what’s to come!

If you have any other questions not addressed here, please don’t hesitate to contact us via email at theater.aspi@gmail.com or by calling our box office at 920-826-5852. We are looking forward to speaking with you!

Chitty Chitty Bang Bang

Cast of Chitty Chitty Bang Bang

Take a fantastic musical adventure with an out-of-this-world car that flies through the air and sails the seas. Based on the record-breaking West End production and the beloved film, and featuring an unforgettable score by the Sherman Brothers (Mary Poppins), Chitty Chitty Bang Bang JR. is one blockbuster that audiences will find “Truly Scrumptious.” Eccentric inventor, Caractacus Potts, sets about restoring an old race car with the help of his children Jeremy and Jemima. They soon discover the car is magic, and has the ability to float and take flight. When the evil Baron Bomburst desires the magic car for himself, the family joins forces with Truly Scrumptious and Grandpa Potts to outwit the dastardly Baron and Baroness and their villainous henchman, the Child Catcher. Filled with amazing stage spectacle and unforgettable songs, including the Academy Award nominated title song, Chitty Chitty Bang Bang JR. is a high-flying fun-filled adventure that will dazzle audiences and Broadway Junior Stars alike.

THE CAST

Jenny Potts …………….. Isabella Haglund
Jemimah Potts …………… Molly Weyenberg
Chitty …………………. Natalie Perra, Maria Ronk, Hailey Marquardt, Addison Hock, Jorgie Runnerstrom
Caractacus Potts ………… Nick Blaser
Mrs. Coggins ……………. Lindsey Faris
Truly Scrumptious ……….. Emma Ronk
Grandpa ………………… Brady Cox
Miss Phillips …………… Chesney Runnerstrom
Lord Scrumptious ………… Jacob Smith
Baroness ……………….. Betsy Finger
Baron ………………….. Xander Birschbach
Boris ………………….. Trent Van De Walle
Goran ………………….. Gavin Runnerstrom
Toy Maker ………………. Mara Gerner
Fair Announcer ………….. Cassidy Mikol
Violet …………………. Jillian Johnson
Sid ……………………. Anton Nicholson
Turkey Farmer …………… Hannah Nicholson
Soldiers/Chefs ………….. Sophia Dobratz, Fayda Jones, Sophie Nelson
Morris Dancers ………….. Bethany Gintner, Evelyn Gossen, Elyse Finger,Dorothy Gintner, Sunny Weenig
Children’s Chorus ……….. Teagan Tessmer, Evette Campbell, Branny Jones, Amelia Holtger, Lyra Vogel, Anna Flory, Lilah Jones, Elaina Finger, Clara Faris
Child Catcher/Junkman ……. David Jolly

24-Hour Theater: A Memorable, Compact Experiment in Creativity

By L. Gail Irwin

An evil laboratory scientist, a support group for the Undead, and a guidance counselor obsessed with Subway sandwiches were among the characters created and staged at the first ever “24 Hour Theater” event organized by Abrams Spotlight Productions Inc. in early October. 

In my busy schedule, 24 Hour Theater was perfect! The compact, mixed age experiment in creativity and improvisation felt like a grown-up play date with a bunch of friendly strangers. The fact that it was free and open to all ages made it accessible to anyone with the guts to try it, regardless of experience. Ten people decided to do just that.

Ranging in age from 15 to 65, we showed up at the Nancy Byng Community Theater on a Friday night to write, direct and stage six short plays under the quiet, accomplished direction of Mike Eserkaln, ASPI director and owner of ComedyCity De Pere. 

Participants volunteered to write, direct and/or act in short plays that had not been written yet.  After doling out writing assignments using prompts from random Wikipedia articles, the writers went home (or to Denny’s) to write our plays into the wee hours of the morning. 

Early on Saturday, we were back at the theater with plays in hand to cast roles, dig up costumes and props and block out our plays, all while sneaking in time to memorize lines.  By 7 p.m. we were ready to perform for a small but loyal audience of grandmas, spouses and children. 

Thanks to Mike Eserkaln and Brigette Finger of ASPI and my fellow actors and writers for creating this great memory! I hope to spend another exhilarating, yet exhausting, 24 hours with you again!

24 Hour theater
Lustful Youth Cast

Lustful Youth

Lustful Youth cast

Lustful Youth is a fast paced, lots of word play show. Everyone gets to play multiple over the top fun to play characters.

It’s about a guy, Walt, who is contractually obliged to write a soap opera that is statistically perfect to get the biggest audience. As Walt writes, the show is produced (no rewrites!), He has “help” from his imaginary friend/muse Dill, but Dill keeps wanting to make things fun and interesting not statistically planned.

Hilarity ensues as Walt writes himself into his own show. It gets pretty darned zany by the end.

THE CAST
Walt ………………………………………………….. Bobby Buffington
Dill ……………………………………………………. Sydney Surber
Tony ………………………………………………….. Will Knaapen
Deb …………………………………………………… Maggie Monte
Carl …………………………………………………… Travis Rysewyk
April …………………………………………………… Abby Frank

an original work by Mike Eserkaln | eserkaln.com