Watch Everything Go Wrong in Abrams’ Spring Comedy

We invite you to witness the chaos of its spring comedy, “The Play That Goes Wrong.” ASPI will present the show May 8-11 and May 15-18 at the Nancy Byng Community Theater, 5852 Maple St., Abrams.

Mike Eserkaln, the artistic director of Comedy City in De Pere, directs the show. He said audiences are going to love the physical comedy. “There’s never a point where something or someone is not moving during the show, often with hilarious and catastrophic results,” Eserkaln said. “The actors are earnestly trying to perform a play while every conceivable thing that can go wrong, does. Every choice the actors make to fix things is the wrong choice.”

“The Play That Goes Wrong” describes the inept and accident-prone Cornley Polytechnic Drama Society’s attempt to produce an ambitious 1920s murder mystery. Unfortunately, the set is not yet complete, the props start to disappear, actors go missing, and the set begins to collapse. Mayhem ensues, the acting gets worse, and the set becomes increasingly dangerous. The question is whether any of the cast and crew will remain standing, or conscious, by the final curtain! “This show is really an experience, something only live theatre can do,” Eserkaln said. “A number of gags are going to rely on gravity, so each show is going to be a little different.”

The set for the show is a character all by itself. Everything – paintings, furniture, walls, the fireplace – is a thought-out prop that has a hilarious moment of going wrong. Cyndy Sweetland designed the set, and David Jolly engineered it.

“The Play That Goes Wrong” features an ensemble cast, and all of the actors are well-versed in comedy. Eserkaln said his favorite character is Trevor the Lights and Sound guy. “He participates in the chaos just as much as everyone but has the cool-headed detachment that I love about theatre tech people,” he said.

Tickets on sale now by grabbing them on our website or by calling the box office at 920-826-5852.

A Godspell Thank You!

“And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another—and all the more as you see the Day approaching.” – Hebrews 10:24-25 (NIV) 

“The theater is a communal event, like church. The playwright constructs a mass to be performed for a lot of people. She writes a prayer, which is really just the longings of one heart.” – Marsha Norman, playwright 

As we put away the costumes and lights, and our actors return to their lives, we want to express our heartfelt gratitude to the ASPI theater community for the overwhelming support of our production of Godspell. This unique experience not only featured a more intimate seating arrangement but, more importantly, we hope it inspired our audiences to seek out their own communities in the pursuit of creating a “Beautiful City.”

Here are some answers to your burning questions….

1) How can I get involved in an ASPI show? When is your next audition opportunity?

The Play that Goes Wrong is our next production and will be presented May 8th-18th. Follow us on our social media platforms for more information! We also have non-show-related volunteering opportunities available. For more information, please contact us at theater.aspi@gmail.com or call us at 920-826-5852!

2) How can I support ASPI financially?

ASPI is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization that depends on community support, both through volunteers and financial contributions. We have various funds available for donations, each offering Spotlight Sponsor benefits based on the level of donation. Some ongoing campaigns include our “Light the Way” Capital Campaign and the Hollie Surber Memorial Scholarship fund. To donate today or to learn more about our campaigns and Spotlight Sponsor membership benefits, click the link below or visit our website.

3) When do “The Play that Goes Wrong” tickets go on sale?

Tickets for the general public are on sale now! Click on the link below!

If you have any other questions not addressed here, please don’t hesitate to contact us via email at theater.aspi@gmail.com or by calling our box office at 920-826-5852. We are looking forward to speaking with you!

The Play That Goes Wrong

The Play That Goes Wrong

May 8, 9, 10, 11 and May 15, 16, 17, 18

Get your tickets now for a night of mishaps, mischief, and madcap mania! It’s the opening night of the Cornley Drama Society’s newest production, “The Murder at Haversham Manor,” and things have quickly gone from bad…to utterly disastrous. The troupe’s ambitious 1920s whodunit has everything you never want in a show: falling props, collapsing scenery, an unconscious leading lady, a corpse that can’t play dead, and actors who trip over everything…including their lines. How will this eager ensemble battle against all of the disastrous odds? Will they make it to the final curtain call?

An international hit that’s equal parts Monty Python and Sherlock Holmes – The Play That Goes Wrong is full of hilarious perfection.

Abrams Spotlight Productions is thrilled to introduce our cast of “The Play that Goes Wrong”. As the Director says “it’s gonna be a WILD show!”

Cast Name (Role)

  • Chris Mayse (Chris/Director)
  • Maddie Pamperin (Annie/Stage Manager)
  • Jerah Doxtator (Trevor/Lights and Sound Guy)
  • Maggie Monte-Knaapen (Sandra/Florence)
  • Bobby Buffington (Max/Cecil/Arthur the Gardener)
  • Eric Westphal (Perkins/Dennis)
  • Erick Gyrion (Thomas Colleymore/Robert Grove)
  • Matt Worzala (Jonathan/Charles Haversham)
  • Will Knaapen (Stage Crew)
  • Marly Thomson (Stage Crew)
  • Julie Johannas-Frohlinger (Stage Crew)
  • Mike Eserkaln (The Director, for real, he’s really the director of the show)
  • Maggie Dernehl (Assistant Director, the one helping Mike)

Tickets are on sale NOW!

The Play That Goes Wrong

GODSPELL

Godspell logo

Performed by Abrams Spotlight Productions in March 2025, Godspell is a musical in two acts with music and lyrics by Stephen Schwartz and a book by John-Michael Tebelak. The show is structured as a series of parables, primarily based on the Gospel of Matthew, interspersed with music mostly set to lyrics from traditional hymns, with the passion of Christ appearing briefly near the end.

The cast of Godspell:

Jesus

Bobby Buffington

John the Baptist / Judas

Preston Pelegrin

Disciples of Jesus

Carolyn Silverberg

Hayden Beekman

Ali Carlson

Bill Sergott

Glenn Sellen

Teresa Aportela Sergott

Kari Moody

Jerah Doxtator

Maggie Sergott

Brynna Moody

Karen Olson

Hailey Marquardt

Jennifer Harkins

Debra Jolly

Elizabeth Jolly-Haslitt (Director)

A Letter from the Director of Godspell

“And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another—and all the more as you see the Day approaching.” – Hebrews 10:24-25 (NIV) 

“The theater is a communal event, like church. The playwright constructs a mass to be performed for a lot of people. She writes a prayer, which is really just the longings of one heart.” – Marsha Norman, playwright 

“What is community?” “What does it mean to be a part of a community?” “How does tragedy affect a community?” These are some of the questions Godspell asks. In tandem, I ask “What does it mean to do theater?” “What is necessary to put on a show?” Although I had a deceptively religious upbringing – a grade school so Lutheran that it broke away from the synod because the synod wasn’t Lutheran enough, a devoutly Catholic grandma with whom I was very close – the place I found the feelings of a religious community was theater. We didn’t attend church on Sundays, but we did have Sunday matinee tickets to the Weidner center. We usually prayed before meals, but my family was most connected when watching old musicals or movies. And, strangely, at my very Lutheran grade school, we put on full scale secular musicals every year. These musicals were the main times I felt like I fit in or could contribute something to that community.

So for this production, I took Stephen Schwartz’s note about Godspell not being a literal playing out of the book of Matthew but as a formation of a community, and set it in my/our/your community – Abrams Spotlight Productions, now, mid-rehearsal process for an upcoming show. You will not find finished sets, costumes, disco balls, confetti cannons, or magical flying cars (which is totally sacrilege for me), but you will find the essence of performing: actors trying to get their message to the audience and holding the mirror up to nature (paraphrasing Hamlet). The answers to those questions above and what is that message? Just as we interpret the bible, that is for you, the audience, to come to individually. Now more than ever, community is important. Wanting to spread one’s messages, one’s “gospel,” not isolate ourselves from those who do not agree, is vital. “Do justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with your God” – Micah 6:6 (NIV)

“Whatever we accomplish belongs to our entire group, a tribute to our combined effort” – Walt Disney – and I would be remiss if I did not say that Godspell, despite the note above, where I talk about me, is surely the effort of every single person you see here today, and many you don’t see, and many who have influenced and taught me. 

Thank you for being a part of our community, even if only for this performance, and enjoy the show! 

-Elizabeth Jolly- Haslitt, Director of Godspell

A Director Spotlight- Godspell

Godspell is a timeless tale of friendship and love based on the Gospel of Matthew. In this new age production, Jesus’ message of kindness, tolerance, and love plays out onstage using a blend of parables, songs, games, and dare we say tomfoolery!

Liz Jolly-Haslitt offers insight into the upcoming production as only the director can! Liz shares that an incredibly unique element of Godspell’s script is that it is pretty open-ended, which means it is up to the theater putting on the production to determine the setting of the show. So the setting that will be seen on stage will be none other than our very own community!

The production setting will be set in our very own theater, as a kind of rehearsal for a production. This unique spin will create a one of a kind theater experience for the audiences! Firstly, the costumes will be pieces pulled from ASPI’s stock from past shows. Secondly, the theater will be utilizing their seating in a unique way! Not only will actors be playing in the house at times, there will also be some audience seating on the stage. 

In addition to the significant creativity from the openness of the script, the production is also extremely lucky to have such a talented cast! They are really working well as an ensemble and meeting the challenge of the advanced listening to each other required of this show.

Purchase your tickets NOW! Showtimes are March 13, 14, 15, 19, 20, 21, and 22 at 7pm and March 16 and 23 at 1pm. For more information please visit https://abramsspotlightproductions.com/ and call the Box Office with any questions, 920-826-5852.